| Both sides previous revision
Previous revision
Next revision
|
Previous revision
|
like_we_were_enemies_in_a_war [2021/07/21 05:44]
admin [References used in report] |
like_we_were_enemies_in_a_war [2021/07/22 00:21] (current)
admin [References used in report] |
| ^Ref # ^Source ^Statement supports ^Evidence for human rights abuse? ^Comments and criticism ^ | ^Ref # ^Source ^Statement supports ^Evidence for human rights abuse? ^Comments and criticism ^ |
| |R1 |Xinjiang Victims Database, shahit.biz/eng/#filter |no giving out details |No |procedural matter only | | |R1 |Xinjiang Victims Database, shahit.biz/eng/#filter |no giving out details |No |procedural matter only | |
| |R2 |John Sudworth, BBC News, “China’s pressure and propaganda – the reality of reporting Xinjiang,” 15 January 2021, www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-55666153; |denied "unfettered access" |No |procedural matter, completely subjective as to the meaning of "unfettered" | | |R2 |[[John Sudworth]], BBC News, [[www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-55666153 | “China’s pressure and propaganda – the reality of reporting Xinjiang,”]] 15 January 2021, ; |denied "unfettered access" |No |procedural matter; completely subjective as to the meaning of "unfettered"; selective ((Highly selective choice of journalists, human rights investigators; citizen journalists and vloggers ignored)) | |
| |::: |Andrew McCormick, Columbia Journalism Review, “How extensive restrictions have shaped the story in Xinjiang, China,” 16 October 2018, www.cjr.org/analysis/uighur-xinjiang.php; | ::: |No |procedural matter, completely subjective as to the meaning of "unfettered" | | |::: |Andrew McCormick, Columbia Journalism Review, [[www.cjr.org/analysis/uighur-xinjiang.php | “How extensive restrictions have shaped the story in Xinjiang, China,”]] 16 October 2018, ; | ::: |No | ::: | |
| | ::: |Matt Schiavenza, Asia Society, “Why It’s So Difficult for Journalist To Report from Xinjiang,” 23 May 2019, asiasociety.org/blog/asia/why-its-so-difficult-journalists-report-xinjiang; | ::: | No | | | ::: |Matt Schiavenza, Asia Society, [[asiasociety.org/blog/asia/why-its-so-difficult-journalists-report-xinjiang | “Why It’s So Difficult for Journalist To Report from Xinjiang,”]] 23 May 2019, ; | ::: | No | ::: | |
| | ::: |Human Rights Watch, “China’s Weak Excuse to Block Investigations in Xinjiang: Ambassador Claims ‘Unreasonable, Unnecessary Obstacles’ Prevent UN Visit,” 25 March 2020, www.hrw.org/news/2020/03/25/chinas-weak-excuse-block-investigations-xinjiang | ::: | No | | | ::: |[[Human Rights Watch]], [[www.hrw.org/news/2020/03/25/chinas-weak-excuse-block-investigations-xinjiang | “China’s **Weak** Excuse to Block Investigations in Xinjiang: Ambassador Claims ‘Unreasonable, Unnecessary Obstacles’ Prevent UN Visit,”]] 25 March 2020, | ::: | No | ((This article makes a judgement that Xinjiang tours will lack credibility; tours are considered "highly controlled" - however, how does one determine if a tour is highly controlled without knowing what is supposedly being "hidden"? )) Conclusion before evidence| |
| | |R3 |Robin Barnwell and Gesbeen Mohammad, PBS Frontline, “China Undercover,”7 April 2020, www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/film/china/undercover/ |"coordinated effort to prevent speaking to locals |No |This is completely dependent on what access one thinks a journalist should have; vloggers and citizen journalists who have had access not interviewed or cited | |
| | | ::: |Isobel Yeung, Vice News, [[www.youtube.com/watch?v=v7AYyUqrMuQ | “China’s Vanishing Muslims: Undercover in the Most Dystopian Place in the World,” | No | |Fairness ((How is it possible to make this judgement after such a short time?)) | |
| | |
| |
