User Tools
what_they_saw_-_buzzfeed
Differences
This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.
| Both sides previous revision Previous revision Next revision | Previous revision | ||
|
what_they_saw_-_buzzfeed [2021/08/01 01:09] admin [Testimony] |
what_they_saw_-_buzzfeed [2021/08/01 01:19] (current) admin [Rejection of claims] |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
| ==== Rejection of claims ==== | ==== Rejection of claims ==== | ||
| + | The use of inverted commas in statements from officials indicates scepticism or outright rejection of these explanations. No rationale for this scepticism is provided. | ||
| - | In response to a list of questions for this article, the Chinese Consulate in New York said that "the basic principle of respecting and protecting human rights in accordance with China' | + | * In response to a list of questions for this article, the Chinese Consulate in New York said that "the basic principle of respecting and protecting human rights in accordance with China' |
| + | * "The centers are run as boarding facilities ((If this is the case, the calculations made by Killing et al regarding floor area and the possible number of internees are invalidated)) and trainees can go home and ask for leave to tend to personal business. Trainees' | ||
| + | * The government has said that “students” in the camps receive vocational training, learn the Chinese language, and become “deradicalized.” Former detainees say this means they were brainwashed with Communist Party propaganda and forced to labor for free in factories. | ||
| + | * State media reports have emphasized the classroom education that takes place in the camps, claiming that detainees are actually benefiting from their time there ((Given that education achievements for ethnic groups lags the rest of China and that cultural pressure is exerted on girls to become mothers and wives, this would directly address the issue)). | ||
| - | "The centers are run as boarding facilities and trainees can go home and ask for leave to tend to personal business. Trainees' | ||
| - | |||
| - | China' | ||
| ==== Testimony ==== | ==== Testimony ==== | ||
| === Testimony 1 - Nursaule === | === Testimony 1 - Nursaule === | ||
| Line 68: | Line 69: | ||
| * older men and women could not handle standing for many hours and struggled to keep watch | * older men and women could not handle standing for many hours and struggled to keep watch | ||
| * so crowded and tense that arguments sometimes broke out among detainees — but these were punished severely | * so crowded and tense that arguments sometimes broke out among detainees — but these were punished severely | ||
| - | * beating ((reporting on another prisoner)) | + | * beating ((Testimony about another prisoner)) |
| * put a hood over my head | * put a hood over my head | ||
| - | * Nursaule was never beaten | + | * Nursaule was never beaten |
| * put a sack over her head | * put a sack over her head | ||
| * took her to the solitary room | * took her to the solitary room | ||
| Line 76: | Line 77: | ||
| * no window | * no window | ||
| + | == Analysis == | ||
what_they_saw_-_buzzfeed.1627780141.txt.gz · Last modified: 2021/08/01 01:09 by admin
Page Tools
